For many years, tube amplifiers have remained a subject of controversy in the electronic field. People are drawn to their exceptional sound quality, but are often deterred by their high price.

 

In today's discussion, we will delve into the world of tube amplifiers. We aim to gain a comprehensive understanding of this device, explore the reasons behind its comparatively steep price, and examine its advantages and disadvantages in comparison to other amplifiers. So, let's get started.

 

1 What is a Tube Amplifier?

A tube amplifier is an early form of electrical signal amplifier that has stood the test of time. It consists of various components enclosed within a glass container, typically a glass tube, including the cathode electron emission part, the control grid, the acceleration grid, and the anode (panel) lead, all of which are welded to the tube base.

 

Operating within a vacuum, the tube amplifier utilizes an electric field to inject an electronic modulation signal into the control grid. This process results in the amplification or feedback oscillation of signal data with different parameters, which is then obtained at the anode.

 

 

While tube amplifiers were once commonly used in electronic devices such as televisions and radio amplifiers, they have gradually been replaced by amplifiers and integrated circuits made of semiconductor materials in recent years. Nonetheless, in the realm of high-fidelity audio equipment, tube amplifiers with low noise and high stability coefficients continue to be employed.

 

2 Pros and Cons of Tube Amplifier

 

Pros:

1. The tube amplifier has a large input dynamic range and fast conversion rate, allowing for accurate and responsive signal amplification.

 

2. Tube amplifiers often use discrete components and manual wiring, resulting in high build quality and superior performance. Although this may increase the cost, it ensures reliability and durability.

 

3. The open-loop performance of tube amplifiers is generally better than that of transistor amplifiers. They can operate stably without requiring deep negative feedback or phase compensation capacitors, resulting in improved dynamic performance.

 

4. Tube amplifiers are known for their soft and pleasant sound quality. They excel in reproducing low-frequency sounds with clarity and precision, while also delivering smooth and clean high-frequency sounds. They particularly shine in reproducing the nuances of human voices.

 

5. Tube amplifiers offer a smoother and more airy treble, with a sound coloring that appeals to many listeners. The slightly fuzzy and warm sound adds a beautiful character to the audio.

 

6. Tube amplifiers produce even-numbered second harmonics, which enriches the sound and adds pleasing overtones, enhancing the overall audio experience.

 

Cons:

1. The service life of tube amplifiers is relatively low, and certain technical indicators may degrade significantly after one to two thousand hours of use. Regular maintenance and replacement of tubes are necessary to maintain optimal performance.

 

2. Tube amplifiers consume high power and often operate in Class A state, resulting in lower efficiency compared to transistor amplifiers. However, they do not suffer from harmful sound quality factors such as transient intermodulation distortion, switching distortion, and crossover distortion.

 

3. Tube amplifiers are not as lightweight, efficient, or long-lasting as transistor amplifiers.

 

4. Proper ventilation and heat dissipation are crucial for tube amplifiers. Excessive heat can shorten their lifespan, so it is important to keep the temperature as low as possible during operation.

 

 

5. Tube amplifiers are sensitive to vibrations, so it is essential to implement anti-vibration measures to minimize any potential impact on their performance.

 

3 Tube Amplifier VS Solid State Amplifier

A solid-state amplifier is a type of amplifier that uses transistor circuitry to convert an electrical signal into an audio wave. It consists of two amplification stages: the preamp stage and the power amp stage.

 

In contrast, a tube amplifier, also known as a valve amplifier, uses vacuum tubes for amplification. The main physical difference between a solid-state amp and a tube amp is the use of electronic transistors in the former and vacuum tubes in the latter. One notable characteristic of tubes is their pleasant distortion when pushed to their limits, which is absent in transistors.

 

The key difference between tube amplifiers and solid-state amplifiers lies in their sound characteristics. Solid-state amplifiers are ideal for guitarists who require a powerful and clean signal without distortion. However, this lack of natural distortion can make an electric guitar sound brittle. As a result, solid-state amplifiers are more commonly used by bassists and keyboard players rather than guitarists.

 

Compared to tube amps, solid-state amps have several advantages:

 

1. Cost-effectiveness: Solid-state amplifiers are generally less expensive than tube amplifiers. They have fewer components, and the ones they do have are reasonably priced.

 

2. Portability: If you are a gigging musician who needs to transport your amp frequently, weight can be a crucial factor. Tube amplifiers are usually heavier than solid-state amplifiers due to the circuitry required to operate the vacuum tubes, not the tubes themselves.

 

3. Maintenance: Tube amplifiers require regular maintenance. Most gigging guitarists replace their power tubes once a year and their preamp tubes every two years. On the other hand, solid-state amplifiers do not require tube replacements and can function for decades with their original components.

4 Tube Amplifier VS Transistor Amplifier?

A transistor amplifier, as the name implies, is used to amplify power, voltage, or current signals. It has different configurations such as common emitter, common collector, and common base amplifiers. These are the most basic types, and there are also differential and push-pull configurations. Transistor amplifiers are commonly used in audio power amplification.

 

There are several key differences between tube amplifiers and transistor amplifiers:

 

1. Working characteristics and circuit structures:

Transistor amplifiers operate at low voltage and high currents. The working voltage of transistor power amplifiers is typically within tens of volts, with currents reaching several or tens of amperes. Direct-coupled non-output transformer circuits (such as OCL and BTL) are commonly used in circuit designs. Transistor amplifiers can deliver high output power, reaching several hundred watts, and have excellent electrical properties.

 

Tube amplifiers, on the other hand, operate at high voltage and low current conditions. The screen voltage of the final power amplifier tube can reach 400-500V, or even thousands of volts, while the current flowing through the tube is only tens to hundreds of milliamps. Tube amplifiers have a wide input range and fast conversion rates.

 

Tube amplifiers often use discrete components and manual wiring, which results in lower efficiency and higher costs. Transistor amplifiers, on the other hand, typically use a combination of transistors and integrated circuits, with printed circuit boards being widely used. This leads to higher efficiency, stable soldering quality, and better electrical performance indicators.

 

2. Power reserve and anti-overload ability:

A high-fidelity amplifier should have a dynamic range of 120dB to reproduce the full range of sound, from the softest to the loudest. To achieve this, the amplifier must have sufficient power reserve.

 

In the case of a 3:1 dynamic range in audio voltage, the power dynamic range is 9:1, as power is proportional to the square of voltage. For example, a 90W power amplifier can only be turned on to 10W for high-fidelity playback.

 

Transistor amplifiers require a large power reserve to avoid overload distortion. When overloaded, the distortion of the output waveform increases rapidly, which can damage the transistors.

 

Tube amplifiers have a much stronger anti-overload capability compared to transistor amplifiers. In case of overload, the peak of the music signal becomes rounded, but the sound is not significantly distorted. Transistor amplifiers, on the other hand, tend to clip and experience a noticeable deterioration in sound quality.

 

3. Efficiency, life, and cost:

Tube amplifiers are not superior to transistor amplifiers in terms of weight, efficiency, and lifespan.

 

The lifespan of electron tubes is relatively shorter, and certain technical indicators can decline significantly after one to two thousand hours of use. Transistors and integrated circuits have much longer lifespans.

 

Tube amplifiers consume higher power and often operate in Class A state, which reduces efficiency. However, they do not suffer from harmful sound quality factors like transient intermodulation distortion, switching distortion, and crossover distortion.

 

In terms of cost, tube amplifiers are generally more expensive than transistor amplifiers of the same grade. This is mainly due to the high cost of electronic tubes and output transformers. Additionally, the production process of tube power amplifiers is not easily automated, resulting in lower production efficiency.

 

4. Sound quality:

The sound quality of tube amplifiers is generally considered superior to that of transistor amplifiers.

 

Transistor power amplifiers tend to have a dominant presence in the high and mid-high frequencies, with less emphasis on low frequencies. They can sound harsh, especially in the low-frequency range where the sound may lack softness, and in the high-frequency range where it can be sharp and dry. At times, there may be noticeable crossover distortion in the high-frequency range, particularly at higher volumes.

 

However, transistor amplifiers excel in dynamic range and speed, making them well-suited for music with greater dynamics. They perform better in reproducing the sound effects of guns and lightning, for example.

 

In contrast, tube amplifiers offer a softer and more pleasant sound quality. The low-frequency sound is soft and clear, while the high-frequency sound is smooth and clean. Tube amplifiers excel in reproducing the human voice, making them highly valued in this regard.

 

5 Things to Consider When Using a Tube Amplifier

1. It is important to use the tube amplifier within its specified parameters. While it may still function under limit parameters, it will significantly shorten the lifespan of the amplifier. Therefore, it is recommended to operate the tube amplifier within its rated parameters.

 

2. The positioning of components within the device should facilitate proper heat dissipation for the tube amplifier. To regulate the temperature of the tube case, it is essential to adhere to the specific allowable temperature limits for different types of tube amplifiers. For instance, the power output tube should not exceed 90°C during operation.

 

3. Unless using a high-reliability tube amplifier with a specialized structure designed for higher acceleration, other receiver amplifier tubes can only withstand brief exposure to small shocks. Therefore, it is important to ensure proper shock absorption for the tube amplifier during use.

 

4. When using small tubes (such as thumb-finger type) or other tubes without tube bases (but with tube needles), it is crucial to use tube sockets specified by the Ministry of Electronics Industry. This helps prevent cracking or damaging the glass shell of the tubes. When inserting or removing the tube, it should be done perpendicular to the plane of the tube base. Care should also be taken to avoid damaging the contact reed in the tube socket and refrain from using the empty foot of the tube socket as a connecting pad.

 

5. When using an indirectly heated tube amplifier, it is important to ensure that the potential difference between the cathode and the filament does not exceed the specified limit. To achieve this, a dedicated filament transformer is often used for power supply. Additionally, to mitigate the impact of instability in leakage current, a shunt resistance of approximately several ohms can be connected between the cathode and the filament, as long as it doesn't hinder the circuit's operation.

 

6 Why are tube amplifiers so expensive? Are they worth it?

In short, tube amplifiers are expensive because they use preamp tubes and power tubes as the main amplification source. The cost of each tube is around $50, and a single unit may have up to four tubes. Additionally, these amplifiers have more expensive components, larger enclosures, and more complex circuits compared to solid-state amplifiers.

 

Whether tube amplifiers are worth buying is more of a subjective question.

 

If your goal is to build an audio chain that faithfully replicates the input signal, then tube amplifiers are definitely not worth buying.

 

By spending extra money to incorporate tubes into the signal chain, you intentionally distort the sound.

 

It is worth noting that modern high-end A/D/A conversion devices (designed to achieve perfect signal replication) never use tubes. The marketing pitch for tube equipment is that it can alter the sound of your input. Unless you really want a tube amplifier, it is not recommended to purchase one.

 

Now, if your goal is not to accurately amplify the signal but to produce a sound that you personally enjoy, then using tubes may have some benefits.

 

You can listen to some tube amplifiers at different volume levels to determine the sound that you personally prefer. Does this make tube amplifiers worth buying? Keep in mind that there are many ways to generate harmonic distortion (within the analog domain or through digital technology emulation), and many methods are cheaper than tubes because of the high production cost of tubes.

 

The high cost of tubes is not due to engineers struggling to design their unique audio characteristics. The way tube amplifiers color the sound is a relic of history, as past engineers could not compensate for the changes they introduced.

 

Nowadays, many people consider this a valuable characteristic, but as the demand for tubes decreases and their production requires specialized limited-batch manufacturing (compared to the growing demand for transistors), the production cost of tubes becomes relatively higher.

 

In conclusion, before reaching any conclusions, consider whether tube amplifiers are worth buying based on your actual needs. There is no definitive answer to this question.

 

7 How to Extend the Life of the Tube Amplifier?

The issue of the short lifespan of tube amplifiers is often criticized, but it is usually not a problem with the tube amplifier itself, but rather a result of circuit design defects and improper usage. It is important to note that a high-quality tube amplifier must have a properly designed circuit, adequate heat dissipation, and effective shock absorption.

 

During usage, it is crucial to ensure that the tube amplifier has good ventilation and heat dissipation. Excessive heat can significantly reduce the lifespan of the tubes, so it is important to keep the temperature of the tube amplifier as low as possible.

 

Vibration is also detrimental to tube amplifiers, so it is essential to implement anti-vibration measures to minimize vibrations. By achieving these two factors, the lifespan of the tube amplifier can be doubled, at the very least. Therefore, it is necessary to provide sufficient space around the tube amplifier equipment, especially above it, to facilitate proper convection ventilation. If possible, a fan can be utilized to assist with heat dissipation.

 

When the cathode of the tube amplifier has not reached the required temperature, applying high-voltage power immediately can damage the cathode and shorten the lifespan of the tube amplifier.

 

Hence, if the tube amplifier equipment is equipped with a preheating device, it must be utilized. For instance, the filament low-voltage power supply should be turned on first for preheating, followed by the high-voltage power supply. If there is no preheating device, it is advisable not to rush to connect the input signal. Instead, keep the volume at the minimum level and allow the machine to warm up for 20-30 minutes before usage.

 

Using an indirectly heated rectifier tube to supply the high voltage of the entire machine can provide a simple and effective high voltage delay. Additionally, avoid frequently switching the power supply during normal usage.

 

Of course, if the tube amplifier circuit is correctly designed and improper usage is avoided, the tube amplifier should not "die young." It is normal for a tube amplifier to be used for thousands of listening hours.

 

The most common mistakes in circuit design include:

 

1. Setting the potential difference between the filament and the cathode of the tube amplifier too high.

 

2. Applying the maximum value of screen or screen grid voltage to the tube amplifier.

 

3. Setting the filament voltage of the tube amplifier too low or too high.

 

4. Improper installation position of the tube amplifier, leading to electrode overheating, and the absence of a delay device in the high-voltage power supply, etc.

 

Therefore, when designing the circuit, it is crucial to avoid these issues in order to effectively extend the service life of the tube amplifier.

8 FAQ

1. Why are tube amps considered superior?

Tube amps are often regarded as superior due to their ability to produce a more full-bodied and rounded sound compared to transistor gear. The unique characteristics of tube sound cannot be replicated by solid-state gear. However, it is important to note that to fully appreciate the benefits of a tube amp, it should be paired with the appropriate speaker to avoid mismatches.

 

2. What are tube amplifiers used for?

Tube amplifiers, also known as tube amps, are electronic or electromagnetic components used to amplify electric current in devices, thereby improving their performance. They play a crucial role in devices such as hearing aids, where they enhance the sound picked up by the microphone.

 

3. Are tube amps worth the investment?

Contrary to their reputation for requiring high maintenance, tube amps often do not demand excessive upkeep. With proper care, owning a tube amp can be a simple and rewarding experience, particularly due to the exceptional tone they offer.

 

4. How long should a tube amp warm up?

As a general rule, tube amps should be warmed up for at least 20 to 30 minutes before playing the guitar. This warm-up period allows the tubes to reach optimal operating temperatures, ensuring the best performance.

 

5. Why do tube amps sound louder?

When tubes are driven beyond their linear region, the harmonics they produce create an illusion of increased loudness to the human ear. This effect occurs during the first 12db of overdrive, where the sound progressively becomes more distorted.

 

6. How does a tube amplifier function?

A tube amplifier operates by utilizing a power transformer and rectifier in tandem. This combination acts as an electron pump, extracting electrons from the amplifier circuit to create a positive voltage. While the amplifier's electronics require direct current (DC) for amplification, the guitar signal passing through the amp remains alternating current (AC).

 

7. What distinguishes a tube amp from a solid-state amp?

The primary distinction between a solid-state amp and a tube amp lies in the technology used for amplification. Solid-state amps rely on electronic transistors, while tube amps utilize vacuum tubes (valves). Solid-state amps excel at providing maximum headroom, delivering a loud, clean, and undistorted signal.

 

8. Which is better: tube amp or solid-state amp?

Tube amps are generally considered to offer a warmer and more musical tone, as well as a more pleasing distortion. However, they tend to be more expensive initially and require occasional tube replacements. On the other hand, solid-state amps are known for their reliability and durability.

 

9. How often should a tube amp be serviced?

A well-made tube amp typically requires a recap (replacing capacitors) every 10 to 15 years, and tube replacements as needed. However, Fender amps, for example, may go many years without needing a power tube replacement.

 

10. How much wattage is necessary for a tube amp?

For sufficient volume to be heard over a drummer without excessive distortion, a solid-state amp with around 100 watts or a tube amp with around 50 watts is generally recommended. This power output allows for a balanced sound without pushing the amp's volume to its limits.